This summer I will be studying abroad and traveling in Europe. This blog is to collect my thoughts, keep in touch with friends and family, and reflect on my adventures.
6/5/11
6/2/11
Part-Time Teaching...Part-Time Dedication?
One topic that has come up in several of the schools that we have visited so far is the issue of part-time teachers in the Netherlands. All public schools in the country have staff members that are both full and part-time teachers. Unlike long-term subbing in the US, these are teachers who have chosen to only work part of the day or part of the week. According to laws in the Netherlands, schools have to accommodate these requests and schedules. This allows teachers to have families and be at home more if they need or want to. When I first heard this option at our first school visit, I was shocked. I would never consider teaching to be a part-time job and I think it goes against a lot we believe in America concerning the difference between part-time jobs and careers. This isn’t just a few people who chose to do this either, at most of the schools we have been to so far, almost half of the teaching staff are part time teachers.
This raises a lot of questions for me. How could a teacher that works half the time be as dedicated as a full time teacher? How do the students react to switching between teachers? How much instruction time is lost on spending time getting the students and the teacher on the same page each day? Does teaching part-time prevent burn out?
The thing that strikes me the most about this issue is that whenever we are told about the part-time teaching staff during our school visits, no principals or administrators feel very positively about it. I think that if it was the way the school worked and it ended up beneficial for everyone, I would just assume that this was an system that worked in Netherlands schools. Instead, principals and other teachers make it seem like a hassle to work around and a frustrating accommodation for their staff.
Last night at Rene’s dinner party, the many of the men and women hosts from the different schools we have visited were there. I got the chance to talk to Nikki, one of the vice-principals at the United World College primary school. We covered so many things, from our own backgrounds and teaching philosophies, to some of the differences in the schools we have both seen. She grew up int he United Kingdom and has taught most primary grades in several different countries. When I asked her about how she felt about part-time teachers in her school, she kind of rolled her eyes. She said that she didn’t feel teachers were nearly as effective if they considered teaching a hobby. She worries that not all teachers equally dedicated to their classroom, so the students she is responsible for get a wide range of attention. She said that for some teachers, having the flexibility and option to continue teaching while raising a family is a wonderful alternative. The can combine something they love without sacrificing time to either. On the other hand, she said that most teachers who only work part-time, do so for selfish reasons. They want more time off, less responsibility, and more choices. She also said that she feels that part-time teachers ask too much of their administration. They are attempting to do the same amount of work with half of the effort, and be rewarded for doing so.
I can’t imagine a system like this ever working in the United States. This is mainly due to the fact that I do not see how part-time teachers would fit into our unions as they are currently. I also do not know how a school district would provide benefits or protections for part-time teachers. This issue is not as pertinent in the Netherlands because of socialized health care.
It seems like the two teachers would spend all of their time catching each other up on what happened on the other’s days off, and not get around to educating. I think this would be a very complicated system for students as well without the proper structure and scaffolding. To me, it seems like being an effective part-time teacher would take even more work than full-time. In turn, I think this means that most part-time teachers are not being successful. It was very difficult to find concrete evidence on how part-time teaching effects students, but I think speaking with Nikki as someone who deals with the issue everyday, is a great way to gain insight. I would also be very surprised that part-time teachers are very willing to participate in any kind of research that may rule them unnecessary. Overall, this is a really intriguing concept and I would like to learn more about the interaction between part-time teachers and their students. Hopefully I will get a chance to see both a part-time and full-time teacher’s instruction during my time observing at the United World College next week.
6/1/11
Day 11 - Aachen, Germany
I was most struck by the way the teachers at this school spoke about their students. They repeatedly said that their school was the last choice of anyone in the area and that it was full of students that were pretty much 'left over' after all of the more affluent students had chosen their schools. She said that they had lots of discipline and behavior problems and that her students were overall really low performing. Another thing that was really interesting to me was that at this school, the students stayed in the same classroom and the teachers rotated rooms when the subjects changed. This meant that each room was not personalized and had nothing on the walls and no materials to use. This really bothered me because I think it makes a really uncomfortable atmosphere for the students, and it was not inviting at all. On that same note, when we asked if students participated in extracurriculars, the teacher and principal both kind of laughed at us. They said that students were not interested in being at school any longer than they were forced to be.
After the visit we stopped by the Netherlands and American World War I and World War II War Memorial. It was a really beautiful cemetery and monument that is maintained by the American government. We got there right at closing so the manager let us walk to the flag pole and help take down and fold the flag for the evening. We were joined by the Canadian group that is traveling with us, they helped take down the flag too and it was awkward.
In the evening, Rene had a party for us at his house. We were joined by the teachers, principals, and administrators that we had met so far. It was a really nice opportunity for us all to talk more and interact informally. The night was beautiful and it was a really nice way to spend the evening.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)